I love Edgeworth. Not quite as much as I love Phoenix Wright, but I love him all the same, dignified dork that he is. I’m sure a lot of people love him too. But I can’t help but feel apprehensive about his spinoff. For some reason I’m reminded of Square and its torrent of fan-serving FFVII subtitles – all these prequels with the Turks and Zack, etc (I’ve never touched any of them, so I don’t know if they’re any good).
It’s not that I detest the idea of Edgeworth having his own game. I actually like the idea of him and Gumshoe running around and solving crimes. On a more personal note, I may be a bit let-down at the seeming lack of courtroom action, which was what reeled me to the GyakuSai games in the first place; the linear and text-dependent gameplay made it easier to stop and resume a case as opposed to quitting the game in the middle of a dungeon or world map and then forgetting where you are and where you’re going. But I digress.
GyakuKen is said to be set as a prequel, which I find appealing, especially if characters like the Von Karmas are in it. It’s just that I can’t imagine Edgeworth being a hero with the most noble causes at this point in time. As most of his growth as a character happened during the Phoenix Wright arc, shouldn’t this Edgeworth be a little… well, stagnant? It’s not something I particularly mind, Edgeworth being a stuffy jerk with his brand of sarcasm, since that’s how he should be, but I’m not sure if Capcom is writing him that way since they probably have fanservice in mind. I just don’t want him to become another Cloud Strife, who nulled the events of FFVII in his personality in Advent Children. If Edgeworth becomes a hero – or encounters some sort of tribulation that would shape him into one – he’d be disregarding the impact the Phoenix Wright arc had on his life and perspective as a prosecutor, wouldn’t he?
Oh, well. Only time will tell.
Posted by sforzando
Posted by sforzando 


Posted by sforzando 

